Merry Christmas, my friends! Today’s holiday-themed topic is all about my favorite portrayals of Jolly Old Saint Nick. This legendary gift-giving extraordinaire has been interpreted in many creative ways over the years, with some versions extra memorable in my mind. Plus, this gives me an excuse to talk about some of my favorite Christmas stories! Let’s dive in.

Tim Allen’s Santa Claus from The Santa Clause

I grew up with The Santa Clause trilogy as a Christmas staple, and though every year these movies seem to get cheesier and cheesier, Tim Allen’s performance is still one of my favorite depictions of Santa. The idea of Santa as a figure who can be replaced by anyone who accidentally knocks him off the roof was genuinely how I thought Santa worked as a kid, and the concept remains The Santa Clause’s most unique innovation of the legendary figure. In fact, basically everything about Santa and the North Pole that I used to believe as a child comes from these movies, so there’s a nostalgic factor with Tim Allen’s performance, too.

As a related honorable mention: Martin Short’s Jack Frost from The Santa Clause 3 is also great, as he’s a fantastic antagonist. Plus, when Jack Frost becomes Santa, his costume design is especially well done. 

Kurt Russell’s Santa Claus from The Christmas Chronicles

While Netflix’s The Christmas Chronicles aren’t my favorite Christmas movies ever, their biggest highlight is their take on Santa. While not exceptionally creative in terms of reinventing the character, Kurt Russell adds an element of coolness and snark to Santa’s character that makes him relatable. Santa’s magic is also well done in these movies, especially in the first one. Kurt Russell’s portrayal also reminds me of my dad, which is another factor in why I like this version of Santa.

Dr. Drummer from Eureka

If you’re unfamiliar with the show Eureka, it’s a mid-2000s sci-fi TV series following the adventures of Sherriff Jack Carter, who works in a small town comprised of super smart scientists who often get into messes caused by their own experiments. It’s a fun series, and the two Christmas episodes (“O Little Town” and “Do You See What I See”) in particular are fantastic. These episodes feature a mysterious reoccurring character: Dr. Drummer. While technically the show never confirms that Dr. Drummer is Santa, all signs point that way, framing Kris Kringle’s “magic” as mere scientific excellence, per the focus of the show. It’s clever and adds some intrigue that fits well with the overall tone of the series.  

Umbrella Santa, AKA “Marty,” from Christmas with the Kranks

Similar to Eureka’sDr. Drummer, the movie Christmas with the Kranks also has a “twist” Santa. Marty randomly pops up in the film, and confuses the characters as he seems to know everyone, while no one can place who he is. He’s quirky and adds to the comedic charm of the movie, and at the end, is strong implied to be the real Santa Claus. For as mundane and ordinary as the movie’s plot is, this spontaneous touch of magic and mystery adds even more Christmas spirit to the film. I also appreciate Marty / Santa’s portrayal as somewhat awkward yet extremely kind, as it feels true to what Santa, as someone who lives a rather isolated life yet clearly likes people enough to bring presents to all the children of the world, would truly be like.

Santa Claus from Phineas & Ferb

Just like with the Halloween episodes in October, Phineas & Ferb’s “Christmas Vacation” is a personal must-watch when December rolls around. I love the decision to framing Santa Claus as Phineas’s hero because of how much the magical gift-giver accomplishes in one single night. Absolutely brilliant. Though Santa himself doesn’t have much screen time, his character is used so perfectly as the underlying reason why everything in the episode happens the way it does.

Klaus from Klaus

I love Netflix’s Klaus. It has to be my favorite recent Christmas movie release, if not current favorite Christmas movie, period. Klaus as Santa Claus’s origin story works so well, beautifully and creatively constructing the backstory for the Santa legend in place today. It’s truly impressive how many pieces of Santa lore are stuffed into this gorgeous film. Also, Klaus as a character is intriguing, with a touching and sad backstory that humanizes the mythical figure of Santa.

Father Christmas from J. R. R. Tolkien’s Letters from Father Christmas

I talked about this book in a Reading Recap last year, and highly recommend it for all fans of Lord of the Rings. Plus, it gives me an excuse to talk about my favorite author once again. Tolkien’s Santa, for Father Christmas, is so magical and wonderful, especially for my fellow Tolkien fans. The book is a collection of letters written by “Father Christmas” to Tolkien’s children, relating funny tales of antics happening in the North Pole. As the years progress, the adventures in the North Pole become more elaborate, some even involving battles with Goblins in true Middle-earth fashion. It’s such a creative concept, and while the story isn’t necessarily the most cohesive, it’s still endearing and a very fun take on Santa.

North from Dreamworks’ Rise of the Guardians

My favorite depiction of Santa has to be North from Rise of the Guardians. The film is such an underrated gem, and I especially appreciate its portrayal of Santa as a sword-wielding, jolly warrior who would do anything to protect the children of the world. North’s portrayal balances both the traditional lore associated with the Santa legend with an absolutely epic depiction. He is the ideal version of Santa, in my opinion.

*

Who’s your favorite portrayal of Santa Claus?